Having
written about a visit to the DMZ and Panmunjom
from the North (Journey into Kimland), I figured
it was time to try writing something about the far more popular visits
from the South. There are already numerous resources on the Net providing
specific tour info (more on that below) so what I'm going to focus
on here is providing some general background and a comparison of my
impressions
with those of others, for example, the recent article
on the DMZ in National
Geographic.
First though, tour
info. For those of you looking to take a tour of
Panmunjom and
the
DMZ from the South I would mainly recommend the USO in Seoul at http://uso.org/Korea/.
You could also try the Panmunjom Travel Center at http://panmunjomtour.com.
Please keep in mind that the South Korean government does not currently
allow its citizens to visit Panmunjom without prior government
approval.
For those looking to visit from the North I would suggest DPRKorea Infobank at http://dprkorea.com/ or
Koryo Tours at http://koryogroup.com/.
Please keep in mind that it is normally extremely difficult, if not impossible,
for U.S. passport holders to get North Korean tourist
visas. |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
View into North Korea from Panmunjom |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Now,
on to the traveling. Most articles I've read on the DMZ tend to focus
on the danger and the militaristic
aspects of the place. It seems that without fail you're going to get
these three comments in every article:
- an ironic comment
on how militarized the De-Militarized Zone really is
- a comment on how this is the world's most heavily defended border, with hundreds
of thousands of NK soldiers poised to swoop into Seoul
- a comment on how "two-thirds" ("70%", "the vast majority") of the North Korean army is stationed along the border, or within a
few hours of the border
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
No arguments here
- it is a dangerous, militarized place. There are a
lot of soldiers along the border. But a couple of these comments can
be misleading and seem designed more to heighten interest or sell stories
than to portray the reality of the ongoing confrontation at the DMZ.
First
off, why wouldn't the vast majority of North Korean soldiers be along
the border with the South? Given that their other two borders are with
traditional allies China and Russia, the more interesting fact would
seem to be that at any given time North Korea deploys a 25-35%
of it forces outside it's main threat area. The U.S. isn't
going to withdraw a third of its troops from the DMZ to defend the
Canadian border,
so why does North Korea keep a similar portion of its forces away from
the South?
The short answer
is two-fold. First, they need to keep troops along
the border with China and Russia to prevent starving North Koreans
from escaping and exacerbating a refugee crisis that is beginning
to irritate its two main allies. Second, they are forced to use
a large number of military personnel to run
state-controlled
farms
and
factories
in an effort to ensure and stabilize output. Pertinent info
generally left out of most DMZ stories. |
Close-up of North
Korean soldier
Photo courtesy
Thomas St. John |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The other main
point that is often glossed over, geographically, is how small North
Korea
really is. Most articles somewhat ominously mention
the huge percentage of North Korean troops deployed within a few hours
of the border. In the recent National
Geographic article mentioned above there's a quote about
how 70% of North Korean soldiers are deployed within 12 hours of the
border. 12 hours! Really?!? I've ridden, on a bus, from the DMZ to the
North's Mt. Myohyang in less than six hours. That mountain is easily
two-thirds
of
the way from the DMZ to the Chinese border - meaning I could have traversed
the whole country, south to north, in less than 10 hours. The
fact that 70% of their forces are within 12 hours is not what is surprising
- what is surprising is how they've gotten 30% of their soldiers
more than 12 hours from the border!
The North, the DMZ
and the potential for nightmarish problems are real enough as
is - there's no need to jazz things up to heighten the threat or sell
stories. The next time you see a report on the DMZ or confrontation
at the border please see how many of the above points the reporter
includes.
Whew, with that off my chest let's get back to traveling. |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The blue building on the left is in South Korea, the white building is in the
North - in between is The Bridge of No Return |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The
one thing that never fails to surprise me when I visit the DMZ is the
utter peacefulness. From all the media reports describing it as 'the
world's most heavily defended border', you would never expect a quiet
countryside
full of farms and small forests. But that's usually exactly what
you get. I say usually here because the stillness
is occasionally shattered when one side blasts propaganda at
the other. But if you're lucky enough to be there when the loudspeakers
fall silent, the place really can seem eerily quiet.
Troops are mainly
kept just outside of the DMZ, hence the term De-Militarized Zone. This
is on both sides of the four kilometer (about 2.5 mile) wide band
stretching across the entire width of the Korean peninsula. A band
of emptiness
that has made the DMZ itself, landmines or not, such a haven for wildlife
that South Korean environmentalists are calling upon both governments
to preserve the area as a national park after reunification. It seems
that 50 years without any people has turned the place into one of the
best wildlife refuges in East Asia.
Even the approaches
to the DMZ seem relatively normal on each side. In the North it's mainly
the same empty countryside one sees outside of Pyongyang, while in
the South it's busy small towns interspersed with quiet fields of rice
paddies. The main clue in the South that you're nearing the border
is the occasional narrowing of the road as it goes under a large block
of concrete. If you look carefully as you go past you can see the supports
for the concrete are designed to be blasted out of the way, dropping
the blocks across the road and hopefully slowing any North Korean advance
on Seoul.
Most tours of the
DMZ, from Pyongyang or Seoul, will take you to the most historically
interesting part of the dividing line, the Joint Security Area (JSA),
also called 'Panmunjom'
(here the 'pan' is pronounced like the 'pon' in pond, the 'mun' like
moon, and the 'jom' like, well, 'jawm'). The JSA/Panmunjom
is what most people are referring to when they talk of visiting the
DMZ. This area was the home of the negotiations that finally
halted the Korean War in 1953, and since then it has been used for
all types of negotiations between the North and South, the North and
U.S.,
and the North and UN. If you see news coverage of meetings
occuring in the DMZ this is the place - on the tours you'll
even get to visit the same building used by the negotiating
teams.
Upon nearing the
JSA tours from both the North and South are remarkably similar. First
you're warned by your guides of how dangerous the area is - this is
the kind of place where a firefight really could break out at any moment.
Both
sides
begin
with a briefing provided by one of the soldiers stationed in
the DMZ. From the South the English briefing is generally conducted
by one of the U.S. soldiers stationed in the area. He (the DMZ is a
relatively woman-less place) will run through the history of the JSA
and provide you with a description and photos of the buildings in the
area, both North and South. After that it's back on the bus for the
short trip north into the heart of the JSA.
The North conducts
a similar briefing, only in Korean while your guides translate. The
North has a large topographical model of the area that a soldier
uses to point out the various buildings and features, while also giving
you background on how the JSA came to be. Once the short briefing is
over (they both take about 10-15 minutes, depending on questions) it's
back on the bus for the short drive south into the heart of the JSA.
Take a look at the
North's topographical model in the picture below for an overview of
the JSA and surrounding area. |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|

Getting our
briefing in North Korea before heading into the JSA
Photo courtesy Dan Harmon
-
the view here is, generally speaking, from the North looking to the South
-
this whole area could be called part of the DMZ, while the
area enclosed in yellow is Panmunjom and/or the JSA
-
the
bridge shown just under the pointer is the Bridge of No Return,
the left side is South Korea, the right side North
Korea
-
the
border here is somewhat oddly shaped, the right and bottom parts
are North Korea, while the center left is South Korea. You can
just make out the border line in brown, curving from the top left of the table down
to the river, and then back left and down through the JSA
-
in
the JSA itself the buildings at the top (mainly in blue) represent
the UN and are in the South, while the pair of larger white buildings
at the bottom belong to the North
-
in
the center of the JSA are three blue buildings all in a row that
are used for meetings between the two sides, you'll enter the center
blue building, shown below, on your tour
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Upon
entering the JSA both sides take you into the heart of the complex -
two large buildings overlooking the actual border line and
the row of buildings that evenly straddle it. The buildings are facing
each other in the photos below. |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
From the
South looking north - the soldiers are South Korean border guards,
the border runs between the two buildings - it's the line in the center.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|

From the
North looking south - the
soldiers in brown are North Korean border guards.
Photo courtesy
Thomas St. John
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| The pictures here were taken months apart while standing
in directly opposite positions. Unfortunately you can't just walk over
the border (without getting shot anyway), basically the only way
from one side to the other is via China. In both pictures
I'm about
50 miles
(80 kilometers)
from my home in downtown Seoul. One trip took me two hours to get back,
the other, three days. |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Notice
how each photo above shows an open door into the same center blue building.
This is where most meetings between the UN/US and
North
Korea are held. It's also one of the highlights of the trip. Each
side allows you to enter the building and look around. As the building
itself is half
in the North and half in the South, once inside you are in
reality moving freely between North and South Korea. Since the war ended
in 1953 this has been the only place on the peninsula where that's been
possible.
Inside the building,
a large conference table goes across the exact center. Down the exact
center of the table is a microphone cord that, in essence,
tells you right where the border runs through the room. Interestingly,
on the
North Korean trip you're free to wander the room at will, whereas on
the trip from the South a guard stands at one end of the conference table,
the end nearest the UN flag, and prevents you from passing on his side.
Everyone is forced to cram themselves around the opposite end of the
table to get to the other side of the room/border.
In case you're wondering
- soldiers always block the opposite side's
door to
prevent
anyone
from
defecting. |

Close-up of border
looking south
- notice how close the soldiers get to each other
Photo courtesy
Dan Harmon

Same place, opposite side
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
South Korean
soldier
guarding the door to the North |
Two North
Korean soldiers
guarding the door to the South
Photo courtesy Dan Harmon |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| In the
South, after touring the conference room, you're taken to a small pagoda
overlooking the heart of the JSA. It makes for great
pictures and a chance to get more of a bird's eye view of the layout. It
also affords you a bit of an angle to examine the North's building. |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Side view
of the North's main building in the JSA |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
What's
the big deal with the side view? Well, for years the U.S. military
was telling unsuspecting tourists that the North's building was
really just a facade. That there really wasn't a building at all - just
the front of a building with nothing behind it. At the time
your only view was dead-center from the front, like in the picture
from the South looking north, above. An angle from which it's impossible
to
judge the depth of the building.
Since the new building
went up a few years ago however, the viewing pagoda was moved to the
right and these side views into the North became
possible. Since then the "just a facade" story seems to have faded away.
When I related this story to my guides in the North, while standing in
their "facade" building, I nearly got into a fight when one of them became
incensed at "the lies of the Americans." More info on that
can be found on the DMZ pages of my trip
to the North. |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
In the North, once you've toured the conference room,
you're led onto the verandah of their building to take some more pictures
and
get one last look at the South.
After that you get
a chance to visit the room where the actual armistice treaty halting
the Korean War was
signed. It's too bad this building isn't halfway in the South as well
-
careful preservation has kept the area emanating history. Sitting
in that room
it's
like
the 50-year-old
treaty
was just
signed a few weeks ago.
After the armistice
room comes a quick visit to a small museum where the North presents
its viewpoint on the outbreak of the Korean War and what has taken
place since. After the museum it's back on the tour bus for the trip
north out of the DMZ.
As for the tour
from the South - once you've toured the conference room it's off to
a small hill overlooking the Bridge of No Return (see pictures
above and below). Then, back on the bus, you're driven past the infamous
'Ax Incident' tree and right up to the South's side of the bridge.
|
Inside the North's
main building in the JSA - Pictures of Kim Il-sung and his son Kim Jong-il
dominate the room, as they do nearly every other important place in North
Korea.
Photo courtesy Thomas
St. John |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Bridge
of No Return - for over 50 years the only way across the DMZ
|
| |
You're
not allowed off the bus near the Bridge, the picture here to the right
was taken through the bus window. Just to the right of the picture
is a
small
memorial to those who died in the "Ax Incident". The incident occurred
in August, 1976 when a group of American soldiers
attempted
to cut down a tree blocking their view of the Bridge from the hill above.
At the time forces
from both sides were free to go anywhere in the JSA - back and forth
across the actual border. A group of North Koreans
set upon the Americans, took the ax they were using on the tree and beat
two of them to death. In the North you can actually see the "military
ax"
on display in the JSA museum. For more on the Ax Incident from Wikipedia click here.
After a brief pause
for pictures the bus then heads south out of the JSA and back down
to Seoul. |
View
into the North across the
Bridge of No Return
|
| |
SK soldiers
checking us out.
Photo
courtesy Thomas St. John
|
One of
the more interesting parts of both trips is how much the other side stares
at you. On the visit from the North the South Korean soldiers (no American
soldiers were visible at the time) monitor everyone quite closely. They
take pictures, scan with binoculars and come right up to the windows
of the conference room to look inside, as in the picture to the left.
On trips from the
South you get similar treatment from the North's soldiers. They'll
come down and look through the windows, plus monitor your group
from the guard post, shown below. |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The
guard post shown here is just to the right of the main North Korean
building overlooking
the DMZ. During the tour, if you look carefully, you should be able
to see yourself being watched and photographed by NK soldiers.
The whole scene,
on both trips, is one of cautious tension. No one wants to look weak
or back down, but no one wants to start a war either. There's plenty
of staring, but no communicating on a personal level, between the two
sides. Usually, the only sounds are those of the tourists, guides and
a few
birds.
Though this isn't
always the case - at times the sides blast propaganda at one-another.
Variously done
to
encourage defections, denigrate the
other side, or just be irritating, it's supposed to have died down
recently from the levels of decades past.
Surprisingly,
unlike what was written in the National
Geographic story, there have been
defections by U.S. soldiers to the North. On page 12 their story mentions
that "there have been no takers," for the
North's
efforts to lure defectors. Back in the 1960s and 70s however there
were reports of U.S. soldiers defecting to the North. Some of them
were later
seen in North Korean movies - ironically mainly playing roles as
"evil U.S. soldiers." |
North Korean guard post overlooking JSA |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Other reports tell
of a U.S. defector who went on to marry
a
Japanese woman
who had been kidnapped by the North in order to train NK spies in
the finer points of Japanese language and culture. As part of the agreements
surrounding Japanese Prime Minister Koizumi's visit to North Korea
in 2002 that woman and
several
other
Japanese kidnapees
were allowed
to return to Japan, though without any members of the families they
had formed in North Korea. Some members of the Japanese press were
then able
to get
an
interview with
this Japanese
woman's
GI husband
(Sgt. Charles Jenkins) in Pyongyang. When asked if he wanted to join his wife in Japan the
former soldier demurred, citing worries about prosecution for desertion
by U.S. military
authorities
should he leave the North. Certainly one of the odder recent stories
to come out of the DMZ . . .
(UPDATE - Jenkins was later released, along with the couple's children, and currently lives in Japan)
For more information on the DMZ, JSA, tours to the Koreas, etc. please
try some of the links below:
- Journey
into Kimland - story of my trip into North Korea, June,
2002
- Korea's
Dangerous Divide - National Geographic, July 2003 (lots
of great pics.)
- Four Decades in North Korea - Far Eastern Economic Review interview with Charles Jenkins on his 40 years in North Korea. (Sept. 1, 2004)
- Emotional
Return for Japanese Abductees - CNN.com story on return
of kidnapped Japanese to Japan, October, 2002
- Living
on the edge of history - JoongAng Daily article on life in
Daesong village, a small South Korean village inside the DMZ
- USO
in Seoul - tours of the DMZ from the South
- Panmunjom
Travel Center - tours of the DMZ from the South
- Koryo Tours -
tours to North Korea
- Joint
Security Area (Panmunjeom) - info on the JSA, Ax
Incident, etc.
- Korean
War Project - KoreanWar.org, info on the war, life
in the DMZ, etc.
- Operation Paul Bunyan - information on the Ax Incident
- KoreaScope - information on North-South unification and other related issues
- Kim's Nuclear Gamble - an interesting look at U.S. - North Korea relations, as well as a wealth of background info on the North, from the Frontline documentary
|
Quote this article | Views: 1591
Powered by AkoComment Tweaked Special Edition v.1.4.6 AkoComment © Copyright 2004 by Arthur Konze - www.mamboportal.com All right reserved |